Lawyer Wellness and the Ringing Phone: What Canada's National Study Tells Small Firms
Canada's first national study of legal professionals' mental health found high levels of distress and burnout. A look at the findings, and at the small daily pressures, like constant interruptions, that firms can actually change.
By VoiceLaw Editorial Team
A profession under strain
In October 2022, the Federation of Law Societies of Canada and the Canadian Bar Association released the first comprehensive national study of the psychological health of Canadian legal professionals. Led by Dr. Nathalie Cadieux of the Université de Sherbrooke, the research surveyed more than 7,300 lawyers, Québec notaries, Ontario paralegals and articling students from every jurisdiction.
Its findings were sobering. More than half of respondents reported psychological distress and burnout. As reported in the CBA's National magazine, 57.5% of respondents experienced psychological distress, compared with about 40% of the Canadian working population. The Phase I recommendations report also found that 37.5% of respondents had experienced suicidal ideation since beginning to practise.
If you or someone you work with is struggling, Canadian law societies fund confidential assistance programs for licensees, and Canada's 9-8-8 Suicide Crisis Helpline is available by call or text, 24 hours a day.
Many causes, some within reach
The study points to many contributing factors: workload, pressure to bill, work-life conflict, the emotional weight of clients' problems, and workplace cultures that make it hard to ask for help. It found that work-life conflict was linked to a substantially higher intention to leave the profession.
Some of these causes require change across the profession. Others are within reach of an individual firm. One of the most ordinary is the steady stream of interruptions that fragments a lawyer's day.
The cost of constant interruption
For a sole practitioner or a lawyer in a small firm, the phone is both a lifeline and a constant interruption. Each call might be a new client, an existing client with an urgent question, opposing counsel, a court office, or a sales call. Because any call could matter, many lawyers feel they have to answer all of them.
The result is a working day broken into short pieces. Drafting a factum, reviewing a closing file or preparing for a difficult conversation all require sustained attention. Being pulled away every few minutes makes that work slower and more stressful, and it pushes focused work into evenings and weekends, which is exactly where work-life conflict grows.
Then there is the anxiety of the calls that are not answered. A lawyer in court knows that prospective clients may be calling and not getting through. Returning voicemails at the end of a long day, often to people who are upset, adds emotional labour to an already full schedule.
Practical steps for small firms
Firms cannot remove every source of pressure, but they can reduce avoidable ones. Some practical measures:
Protect focus time. Block time in the calendar for work that needs concentration, and make sure calls during those blocks are handled by someone or something else.
Separate new enquiries from existing-client calls. Different calls need different responses. Routing new enquiries to an intake process, and existing clients to the right person, reduces the pressure to answer everything personally.
Set clear expectations with callers. A caller who is told when they will hear back is far less likely to call repeatedly than one who reaches only voicemail.
Define what is urgent. Decide in advance which situations need an immediate response (a client in custody, an imminent deadline) and who handles them after hours. Everything else can wait until the next business day without guilt.
Share the load. Even very small firms can arrange reciprocal coverage with colleagues, an answering service, or technology that handles routine calls.
Look after the people doing intake. Receptionists and clerks also absorb callers' distress. Training, clear scripts and permission to hand difficult calls to a lawyer all help.
Where technology helps, and where it doesn't
An AI receptionist will not fix a culture of overwork. It can, however, take one specific pressure off a lawyer's day: the need to personally answer or return every routine call.
Configured carefully, it can answer the phone in the firm's name, disclose that it is an AI assistant, handle simple administrative questions from approved information, collect new enquiries' details for a conflict check, and route urgent matters to the lawyer on call. Everything else arrives as a written summary the lawyer can review at a time they choose, rather than a stream of interruptions.
What it must not do is take over work that requires a lawyer's judgment or empathy. It should never give legal advice, and it should always offer a caller a way to reach a person. Used this way, it supports the boundaries that wellness research encourages rather than replacing human connection.
A healthier practice is a better practice
The national study makes clear that the wellbeing of legal professionals is not a private matter. It affects the quality of legal services, the retention of talented lawyers and, ultimately, the public's access to justice. Small, practical changes in how a firm handles its daily workload, including its phone, are part of building practices where lawyers can do their best work and stay in the profession.
VoiceLaw builds AI receptionists that help Canadian law firms answer every call without interrupting every lawyer. Learn more at https://voicelaw.ai.
Sources
Canadian Bar Association, "The first comprehensive national study on wellness in the legal profession is published" (October 27, 2022)
https://www.cba.org/news/the-first-comprehensive-national-study-on-wellness-in-the-legal-profession-is-published/
CBA National, "Higher prevalence of distress and depression in the legal profession"
https://nationalmagazine.ca/en-ca/articles/the-practice/workplace/2022/higher-prevalence-of-distress-and-depression-in-legal-profession
Cadieux, N. et al., Towards a Healthy and Sustainable Practice of Law in Canada, Phase I: Recommendations (Université de Sherbrooke, 2022)
https://flsc-s3-storage-pub.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/FINAL_RECOMMENDATIONS_Cadieux%20et%20al._2022.pdf
9-8-8 Suicide Crisis Helpline (Canada)
https://988.ca